Picking Between a Tub or a Shower During a Bathroom Remodel

Picking Between a Tub or a Shower During a Bathroom Remodel

Getting a bathroom remade entails a lot of decision-making for any homeowner. One of the key things to consider would be the fixture you’re putting into your bathroom for your everyday bathing needs. Although it’d be ideal to pick both a tub and a shower, some people don’t have the luxury of choosing the two together right away.

Your designers need to understand what bathroom inclusion you’ll be making in order to work out the final look and layout of the area, though. If you’re not exactly set about what to choose for your bathroom remodelling project, here are six different points to consider when picking between a tub and shower:

Installation Price

Remodelling the bathroom and other areas of the home might mean that you’re on a tight budget. If that’s the case, you may want to consider getting a bathtub rather than a shower stall since the former is relatively cheaper than the latter.

Granted, how low the price is can depend on what kind of model and material will be attained for the tub and shower stall. To give you an estimate, a whirlpool tub may cost around $4500 to $8000, while a walk-in shower is about $6000 to $10,000.

Bathroom Space

Smaller homes with even smaller spaces will have to influence your decision. Bathtubs can eat up a lot of space and prevent other inclusions in the bathroom. Although you may settle for a smaller tub, there’s little use or sense for it when it’s cramped.

Showers are perfect if you’re looking for a bathroom fixture that will take up less space. Instead of the tubs that can take up to 32 square feet, most shower stalls just take up less than 10 square feet.


Accessibility in the bathroom is important to think about if any co-occupants in the home are older or immobile. It can be difficult to get in and out of a bathtub without any help, and it’s important to respect their decision not to ask for that aid. Showers are considered more user-friendly. Consider asking your project designer for any ways to simplify access, too. 

Water Efficiency

Expenses don’t stop rolling in after the fixture installation and bathroom remodel. If you want to keep your water bill relatively low, consider getting a shower instead of a bathtub. Showers use less than 20 gallons of water per shower, maybe even less if you keep your session quick. Tubs use more than double of those gallons of water, sometimes more. 

Resale Value

If you want to think ahead about investing in your home in case of a resale, know that most bathrooms with a tub seem to yield a better response in the market. Although everyone would like both bathing options, most homebuyers tend to prefer getting home where the bathroom has a tub instead of a shower for the children.


Lastly, one thing that you want to consider during a bathroom remodel is always preference. You’ll be using the fixture in the long run, after all. Some people like to light up a few candles and soak in a tub when bathing, while others gravitate more towards that quick in-and-out shower. Try to think about which one is more of your style and go with that option instead.


There’s no wrong or right answer to what you should have in your own bathroom. Tubs and showers are both quite different in many areas, but they’re both great fixtures for maintaining your daily hygiene while sprucing up the bathroom in your home. 

Looking for an interior designer in Toronto, ON for your bathroom remodel? Contempo Renovation Solutions Inc. is a full-service construction and project management company with a strong passion for design and quality craftsmanship in residential projects. Contact us today!